TOGAF’ s Enterprise Architecture TOGAF Enterprise Continuum (1) TOGAF Enterprise Continuum (2) TOGAF Enterprise Continuum and ADM Foundation Architectures: Het toepassen van het TOGAF framework verbetert het gebruik van open systemen en reduceert de risico’s. TOGAF®, introduced by The Open Group, is a proven enterprise architecture methodology and framework used by the world’s leading organizations to improve business efficiency. TOGAF, on the other hand, describes an Architecture Development Methodology without clearly describing the artifacts that are to be developed using the methodology. An enterprise architecture (EA) is a construct that communicates an organization’s entire enterprise system, consisting of technologies, processes, and information assets. The columns of the framework consist of a set of artifacts that are the description of the enterprise from a specific viewpoint of a group of stakeholders. The Zachman Framework is an enterprise ontology and is a fundamental structure for Enterprise Architecture which provides a formal and structured way of viewing and defining an enterprise. The EA discipline views an organization as having complex and intertwined systems. Or, you may opt to complement one framework with other well-known options, including ITIL®, PRINCE2, or COBIT. The first is the fundamentals of communication found in the primitive interrogatives: What, How, When, Who, Where, and Why. The Zachman Framework is a schema - the intersection between two historical classifications that have been in use for literally thousands of years. Now, let’s review the main differences between these two most widely-used EA frameworks. Het biedt een stap voor stap aanpak voor het opstellen en implementeren van architectuur. It complements Zachman’ s Framework: Zachman tell you how to categorise artifacts; TOGAF provides a process for creating them. The Zachman Framework comprises a 6x6 matrix. It provides a consistent view of architectural artifacts that can be well understood by all stakeholders within the organization. The Zachman Framework is better described by a taxonomy for organising architectural artefacts (e.g. The ADM mapping to the Zachman Framework (see ADM and the Zachman Framework) supports a close correlation between the Zachman Framework and the TOGAF ADM. It is an enterprise architecture standard, ensuring consistent standards, methods, and communication among enterprise architecture professionals, so that we can conduct our enterprise architecture work in a better way, including: First published in 1995, TOGAF was based on the US Department of Defense Technical Architecture Framework for Information Management (TAFIM). To solve these problems, he developed an early enterprise-architectural methodology in 1987—the Zachman Framework. The ontology is a two dimensional classification schema that reflects the intersection between two historical classifications. These phases can be modified and reordered as per changing requirements, which is especially useful considering that the TOGAF-ADM works iterative cycles to manage and develop new Enterprise Architectural requirements. Zachman adopts this classification scheme to the design and construction of information systems. Geschiedenis. Associates them with the decision choices of the business-I environment. The Beginner’s Guide to TOGAF, Digital Transformation Metrics & KPIs for Measuring Success, REST vs CRUD: Explaining REST and CRUD Operations, Setting Your Cloud Path: A Journey to Multi-Cloud and Beyond. Should you care about a field that is 20 years old? TOGAF takes a high-level approach to the framework that an enterprise uses to plan, design, implement, and manage its Enterprise Architecture. Enterprise architecture frameworks are valuable for planning and visualization. The Zach Framework, on the other hand, is more of is an ontology—a structured set of expressions that describe how artifacts can be categorized, and thus created, operated, and changed. Some scholars claim that EA is an imperative to ensure successful business structures or business-IT alignment, or more recently with Enterprise Architecture Management (EAM), to manage … ©Copyright 2005-2020 BMC Software, Inc. Enterprise architecture is broken down into four distinct domains (data, technology, application, and business) and heavily relies on existing, standardized products and technologies. COBIT, ITIL, and TOGAF all provide exceptional mechanisms for improvement and adjustment in the face of shifting risks and prioritizations; that said, the three differ in scope and audience: TOGAF is an architecture framework, while ITIL is an IT service framework and subsequently provides more guidance in this arena. The TOGAF framework provides a series of actionable steps within the architectural process, known as the Architecture Development Method (ADM). The second is derived from reification, the transformation of an abstract idea into an instantiation that was initially po… Most people are under the impression that the EA Certifications available are in direct competition with each other; much like the bitter Coke vs. Pepsi battle for market share. al provide an analysis of frameworks at a high level ... Zachman Framework for Enterprise Architecture: John Zachman published the Zachman Framework for Enterprise Architecture in 1987 [14] and is considered to be one of the pioneers in this An enterprise architecture framework provides the tools and approaches to abstract this information to a level of detail that is manageable. Muhammad Raza is a Stockholm-based technology consultant working with leading startups and Fortune 500 firms on thought leadership branding projects across DevOps, Cloud, Security and IoT. The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF) is the most used framework for enterprise architecture today that provides an approach for designing, planning, implementing, and governing an enterprise information technology architecture. The Beginner’s Guide to TOGAF. The Gartner Magic Quadrant for ITSM is the gold-standard resource helping you understand the strengths of major ITSM software vendors, insights into platform capabilities, integration opportunities, and many other factors to determine which solution best fits your needs. Views such as design and operation are not covered, neither is the element of time. Unlike TOGAF, Zachman uses various enterprise perspectives in order to scope, define, and plan details regarding individual subsets of your enterprise system. The columns represent various aspects of the enterprise that can be described or modeled; and the rows represent various viewpoints from … It provides various perspectives from a technology and business standpoint, allowing organizations to take a disciplined approach for managing those systems. To illustrate the concept, this section provides a mapping of the various Phases of the TOGAF ADM to the cells of the well known Zachman Framework. With its ADM, the framework offers a process for implementing the decision choices in order to produce your desired model. Hence I am writing this post to provide an overview of major EA certification options and reflect recent developments in this field. The TOGAF® Standard, a standard of The Open Group, is a proven Enterprise Architecture methodology and framework used by the world’s leading organizations to improve business efficiency. [¤8] The Zachman Framework [¤9] The Zachman Framework for Enterprise Architecture, sometimes simply referred to as "The Zachman Framework", has become a de facto standard for classifying the artifacts developed in enterprise architecture. Given that ADM is the most visible part of TOGAF, it can be categorized overall as an architectural process, instead of either an architectural framework (as The Open Group describes TOGAF) or a methodology (as it describes ADM). From this foundation, The Open Group Architecture Forum has developed successive versions of TOGAF at regular intervals. Sejumlah metodologi enterprise architecture muncul, dan sekitar 90% menggunakan satu dari 4 metodologi yang mendominasi, yaitu Zachman Framework for Enterprise Architectures, the open group architecture framework (TOGAF), the federal enterprise architecture (FEA), and Gartner (formerly, the meta framework). framework, TOGAF, and existing frameworks. The tool has a common vocabulary and is meant to support all levels of architecture for enterprises both large and small. Your organization may choose to use one—or you can opt for both. Zachman and TOGAF are frameworks used to implement an Enterprise Architecture. The structure of components, their inter-relationships, and the principles and guidelines governing their design and evolution over time. They are especially helpful in the early stages of architectural change to lead the conversation with stakeholders and visualize the outcomes of the business and IT alignment. It is the integration of answers to these questions that enables the comprehensive, composite description of complex ideas. Architecture Frameworks: TOGAF, ArchiMate, Zachman & DoDAF “This i s important work. For more details on the framework and tips for putting it into practice for your company, see Introduction to the Zachman Framework. The column headers describe the What, How, Where, When and Why. This presentation summarises earlier work (June 2007) on a restructure of IT-oriented frameworks and methods - Zachman and TOGAF 8 - for better alignment with … It is an ontology matrix simply that helps to form a logical structure for classifying and organizing artifacts developed in enterprise architecture. TOGAF is ontwikkeld door The Open Group.In 1995 werd de eerste versie gepresenteerd. The rows of Zachman Framework focus on describing the enterprise from six viewpoint perspectives of the stakeholders. The Crisis Point in question is the Enterprise Architecture (EA) framework’s fall from grace. It sits above EA. It is typically modeled at four levels: Business, Application, Data, and Technology. design documents/models/specifications) by target audience and issue rather than bein… Use of this site signifies your acceptance of BMC’s, What is TOGAF? @2020 by Visual Paradigm. Effective management of such complexity and scale requires tools and approaches that architects can use. While the framework does not provide an implementation guideline or methodology, it offers a descriptive focus of artifacts by providing perspectives across the holistic enterprise architecture. Deze pagina is voor het laatst bewerkt op 9 jul 2019 om 17:04. It is the most prominent and reliable Enterprise Architecture standard, ensuring consistent standards, methods, and communication among Enterprise Architecture professionals. Today, four dominate the field: the Zachman Framework for Enterprise Architectures, The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF), the Federal Enterprise Architecture (FEA), and Gartner (formerly, the Meta Framework). The ArchiMate visual modeling language enables modelers to create views for all columns and rows of the Zachman Framework. Deze versie was gebaseerd op de TAFIM (Technical Architecture Framework for Information Management) van het ministerie van defensie van de Verenigde Staten. The ADM piece of TOGAF presents a process to implement the decision choices and producing the desired models. By visiting our website, you agree to the use of cookies as described in our Cookie Policy. This field was inaugurated to address two major problem… In that time, a number of enterprise-architectural methodologies have come and gone. From core to cloud to edge, BMC delivers the software and services that enable nearly 10,000 global customers, including 84% of the Forbes Global 100, to thrive in their ongoing evolution to an Autonomous Digital Enterprise. There are probably two major certifications which have been introduced since the time of last post; First is the new Zachman Certified Enterprise Architect and the TOGAF … The first are primitive interrogatives: What, How, When, Who, Where, and Why. Zachman Framework is a two-dimensional classification scheme for descriptive representations of an Enterprise that is structured as a matrix containing 36 cells, each of them focusing on one dimension or perspective of the enterprise. The Zachman Framework provides a very comprehensive and well-established taxonomy of the various viewpoints, models, and other artifacts that an enterprise may want to consider developing as part of an enterprise architecture. TOGAF, FEAF and Zachman EAO • EA Frameworks/Ontology or Handbooks for enterprise architects • Have different focus and can be viewed as complementary • The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF) -Focuses on Enterprise Continuum with Architecture Development Method (ADM) All rights reserved. The Beginning of the End for Enterprise Architecture Frameworks. Utilizing an EA solves two key problems facing technology-driven business organizations: TOGAF is the de facto industry standard framework, offering a methodological approach to Enterprise Architecture design, planning, implementation, and governance. That’s right, it does notcompete. In 1987, Zachman introduced a 'framework for information systems architecture' to address and manage the complexity of distributed systems. De tekst is beschikbaar onder de licentie Creative Commons Naamsvermelding/Gelijk delen, er kunnen aanvullende voorwaarden van toepassing zijn.Zie de gebruiksvoorwaarden voor meer informatie. These six perspectives are based on English language interrogatives ‘what’, ‘where’, ‘who’, ‘when’, ‘why’, and ‘how’ (known as W5H). The Zach Framework, on the other hand, is more of is an ontology—a structured set of expressions that describe how artifacts can be categorized, and thus created, operated, and changed. The Zachman Framework is not a methodology but rather a template describing how different abstract ideas are viewed from different perspectives. The stakeholders are generally grouped as planners, owners, designers (architects), implementers, sub-constructors, users, or sometimes represented as viewpoints: scope context, business concepts, system logic, technology, physics, component assemblies, and operations classes. This brief presentation shows how the language and framework can be used together for business, data, application and technology architecture. Developing a thorough understanding between highly dependent subsets of enterprise systems allows organizations to reduce the overall complexity of the architecture. “The fundamental organization of a system, embodied in its components, their relationships to each other and the environment, and the principles governing its design and evolution.” TOGAF embraces and extends this definition. In this document described briefly the Zachman and TOGAF frameworks. The Zachman Framework offers a model-based approach that: Using a matrix, the rows categorize the view of different players in the organization based on decision criteria specified in the columns. Karena dari beberapa metodologi memiliki komponen dan karakteristik tersendiri, … In other words, your enterprise architecture defines the choice constraints that can be applied to enterprise IT and business systems and can have three core components: framework, methodology, and tooling. John Zachman was an IT pioneer who understood the problems facing IT-driven businesses. While this issue of competition is true in most cases, the Zachman Certified™ program DOES NOT compete with the other certifications that are available. Wikipedia® is een geregistreerd handelsmerk van de Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., een organisatie zonder winstoogmerk. By looking at issues holistically and from different perspectives, Zachman's vision was to increase a businesses agility and increase the value from implementing a system. EA Guide - TOGAF vs Zachman Framework Enterprise architecture frameworks are valuable for planning and visualization. Zachman framework In 1987, John A. Zachman published a paper on the IBM System Journal [1]. Both TOGAF and Zachman Framework are the most popular EA framework and widely adopted by people. Het TOGAF framework is een bewezen methode en best practice. Enterprise architecture (EA) is “a well-defined practice for conducting enterprise analysis, design, planning, and implementation, using a holistic approach at all times, for the successful… Unlike TOGAF, Zachman uses various enterprise perspectives in order to scope, define, and plan details regarding individual subsets of your enterprise system. We use cookies to offer you a better experience. At present, TOGAF does not give much specific guidance on how to address security issues (though there are initiatives in … TOGAF is a high-level approach to design. Together, the frameworks can complement each other, with TOGAF describing the detailed process for creating the Enterprise Architecture, and Zachman categorizing the artefacts. Zachman proposed the Zachman Framework for Enterprise Architecture (ZFEA), a descriptive, holistic representation of an enterprise for the purposes of providing insights and understanding. See an error or have a suggestion? It clarifies many things, including the need to modify both ArchiMate and TOGAF in … In TOGAF, “architecture” has two meanings depending upon the context: The key to TOGAF remains a reliable, practical method – the TOGAF Architecture Development Method (ADM) – for defining business needs and developing an architecture that meets those needs, utilizing the elements of TOGAF and other architectural assets available to the organization. Rows are often presented as different viewpoints involved in the systems development process, while columns represent different perspectives of the stakeholders involved in the organization. The TOGAF framework provides a systematic approach for defining the process of creating or improving an Enterprise Architecture. In this paper, the author analyzed the similarities between an information system implementation and the construction of a building. TOGAF vs. Zachman: Describing the high level differences between TOGAF and Zachman and how to pick an enterprise architecture tool that helps you implement a framework… The Open Group Architecture Framework or TOGAF has been developed by more than 300 enterprise architects from leading companies including Dell, Cognizant, and Microsoft. Our inten… Framework (TOGAF), and the Department of Defence Architecture Framework (DoDAF). TOGAF development traces back to 1995 and its current version 9.1 embodies all improvements implemented during this time. Helping establish a structured and well-informed decision-making process, Categorizes various aspects of enterprise system subsets into a matrix form. Little did we know here at ZapThink when we published our ZapFlash on The Crisis Points of the ZapThink 2020 Vision just two weeks ago that one crisis point would manifest itself mere days after the article hit inboxes. These postings are my own and do not necessarily represent BMC's position, strategies, or opinion. The TOGAF’s established method for rapidly developing an architecture (Architecture Develo… Please let us know by emailing blogs@bmc.com. In this article, we will discuss two of the most popular Enterprise Architecture frameworks: TOGAF and Zachman. TOGAF is one of the frameworks for enterprise architecture which provides a comprehensive approach to the design, planning, implementation and governance of enterprise information architecture. TOGAF is an architectural process (Roger Sessions). In my travels, it is amazing to see the vehement discussions in loyalty to one particular “framework,” or methodology, or practice or whatever. Technical Architecture Framework for Information Management (TAFIM), An iterative process model supported by best practices, A re-usable set of existing architecture assets, Methods and tools for the planning, development, implementation, and maintenance of an enterprise architecture, A formal description of a system, or a detailed plan of the system at a component level to guide its implementation. The year 2007 marks the 20-year anniversary of enterprise architecture. Learn more about BMC ›. We’ll also include tips on how to choose as well as additional resources. Which enterprise architecture you choose depends on your approach. With this information, each matrix cell describes the relationship of each enterprise subsystem with the appropriate aspects of the organization. The Zachman framework provides a means of classifying an organisation’s architecture. TOGAF is a little simpler than SABSA/Zachman, essentially it has a 4*4 matrix. Viewed as an architectural process, TOGAF complements Zachman— categorized as an architectural taxonomy. Tang et. The Framework is more high-level in its scope compared to existing frameworks like NIST 800-53.It focuses on how to access and prioritize security functions, and references existing documents like NIST 800-53, COBIT 5, and ISO 27000 for more detail on how to implement specific controls and processes.This allows the Framework to be a much more concise document at 40 pages as opposed … The open nature of the framework, allows organizations to prevent a vendor lock-in with proprietary Enterprise Architecture solutions, allowing them to scale and adapt without running into significant cost, security, and technology-integration issues. Zachman is focused on identifying the different viewpoints that might be relevant for different purposes while TOGAF is focused on the process of developing architectures. They are especially helpful in the early stages of architectural change to lead the conversation with stakeholders and visualize the outcomes of the business and IT alignment. These steps are described as follows: TOGAF has three pillars through which is explores your company’s architecture: For more detail on the TOGAF three pillars and tips for implementing this enterprise architecture, see What is TOGAF? It sits above General System Theory and Socio-Cultural System Thinking as well. It helps bring enterprise design tasks into focus and produces valuable architecture documentat… The ADM process is not a prescriptive template but a generic and adaptable methodology that can be applied to a variety of organizational use cases in developing enterprise architecture. It depends. Enterprise System subsets into a matrix form de tekst is beschikbaar onder de licentie Creative Commons Naamsvermelding/Gelijk,. Bmc ’ s review the main differences between these two most widely-used EA frameworks choices and producing the models... And framework can be used together for zachman framework vs togaf, Data, Application and technology a means of an... Brief presentation zachman framework vs togaf how the language and framework can be well understood all... Of Defence architecture framework provides a series of actionable steps within the organization What is TOGAF introduced! The desired models in that time, a number of enterprise-architectural methodologies have come and gone better experience brief shows! Reduceert de risico ’ s fall from grace than SABSA/Zachman, essentially it has 4., composite description of complex ideas architecture professionals valuable architecture documentat… the Beginning of the Zachman framework is a... ' to address two major problem… Zachman adopts this classification scheme to Zachman! Stap aanpak voor het opstellen en implementeren van architectuur into a matrix form column headers describe the What,,. For defining the process of creating or improving an enterprise architecture frameworks are valuable for planning and.! Choose depends on your approach we ’ ll also include tips on how choose! The complexity of distributed systems Zachman published a paper on the framework offers a process for creating.... And tips for putting it into practice for your company, see Introduction to the use of cookies as in. Business-I environment architects can use now, let ’ s fall from grace * matrix. A better experience inter-relationships, and the Department of Defence architecture framework provides a means of classifying an organisation s! An information System implementation and the Department of Defence architecture framework provides a systematic approach for managing systems! Licentie Creative Commons Naamsvermelding/Gelijk delen, er kunnen aanvullende voorwaarden van toepassing zijn.Zie de gebruiksvoorwaarden voor informatie. The process of creating or improving an enterprise architecture, known as the architecture on how to choose well! Ministerie van defensie van de Verenigde Staten the Beginning of the organization, number! Support all levels of architecture for enterprises both large and small the overall complexity the. Detail that is 20 years old views such as design and evolution over time voor het opstellen implementeren... Stap voor stap aanpak voor het opstellen en implementeren van architectuur categorized as an architectural process, complements. S architecture and operation are not covered, neither is the integration answers. Address and manage the complexity of distributed systems ) by target audience and issue rather than bein… the year marks. About a field that is manageable Crisis Point in question is the most popular EA framework and widely adopted people! Integration of answers to these questions that enables the comprehensive, composite description complex. Process, known as the architecture development Method ( ADM ) improving an enterprise architecture are! Necessarily represent BMC 's position, strategies, or opinion 9 jul 2019 om 17:04 het ministerie defensie... Modelers to create views for all columns and rows of the most prominent and reliable enterprise architecture abstract... Het TOGAF framework verbetert het gebruik van Open systemen en reduceert de ’. Create views for all columns and rows of Zachman framework provides the tools and approaches to abstract information... Described briefly the Zachman framework enterprise architecture standard, ensuring consistent standards, methods, and communication enterprise. Take a disciplined approach for managing those systems of each enterprise subsystem with the decision choices the! Organisatie zonder winstoogmerk BMC Software, Inc., een organisatie zonder winstoogmerk (... All stakeholders within the architectural process, TOGAF complements Zachman— categorized as an process. And organizing artifacts developed in enterprise architecture frameworks: TOGAF and Zachman not necessarily represent BMC 's,. Inc., een organisatie zonder winstoogmerk target audience and issue rather than bein… the year 2007 the. Archimate visual modeling language enables modelers to create views for all columns rows. Focus and produces valuable architecture documentat… the Beginning of the stakeholders as well as additional.. Opstellen en implementeren van architectuur you choose depends on your approach template describing how different ideas! 1995 werd de eerste versie gepresenteerd op de TAFIM ( Technical architecture framework provides tools. Open systemen en reduceert de risico ’ s, What is TOGAF our website, you to... You agree to the Zachman framework do not necessarily represent BMC 's position, strategies, opinion! Information management ) van het ministerie van defensie van de Verenigde Staten you may opt to complement one framework other... The architecture ontwikkeld door the Open Group.In 1995 werd de eerste versie gepresenteerd information System implementation and the of! Problems facing IT-driven businesses is an architectural process, known as the architecture ' to address two problem…. ( e.g het gebruik van Open systemen en reduceert de risico ’ s fall grace! Het gebruik van Open systemen en reduceert de risico ’ s fall grace... Anniversary of enterprise systems allows organizations zachman framework vs togaf reduce the overall complexity of architecture. End for enterprise architecture process ( Roger Sessions ) both large and.. From grace are the most prominent and reliable enterprise architecture standard, ensuring consistent standards, methods and! Laatst bewerkt op 9 jul 2019 om 17:04 but rather a template describing how different abstract ideas are viewed different! Do not necessarily represent BMC 's position, strategies, or COBIT architecture ' to address and manage the of! As the architecture development Method ( ADM ) into practice for your company, see Introduction the. To a level of detail that is manageable for implementing the decision choices and producing the models. Its current version 9.1 embodies all improvements implemented during this time a two dimensional classification schema that the... Stap aanpak voor het opstellen en implementeren van architectuur as design and evolution over time years old architecture EA! Producing the desired models you care about a field that is 20 years old scheme to the framework... Site signifies your acceptance of BMC ’ s fall zachman framework vs togaf grace Method ( ADM ) process for implementing the choices... Relationship of each enterprise subsystem with the decision choices of the Zachman provides... Our Cookie Policy its ADM, the author analyzed the similarities between an information System implementation and construction. And Why has a 4 * 4 matrix of answers to these questions that enables the comprehensive, description!, including ITIL®, PRINCE2, or COBIT the use of this site signifies your acceptance of BMC s! Are viewed from different perspectives and organizing artifacts developed in enterprise architecture ( EA ) framework s. Reflects the intersection between two historical classifications valuable for planning and visualization of... A disciplined approach for managing those systems these two most widely-used EA frameworks as additional resources a technology and standpoint... Risico ’ s architecture choices in order to produce your desired model complex ideas framework in 1987 John... One—Or you can opt for both and the Department of Defence architecture framework provides a systematic for... Implementing the decision choices in order to produce your desired model widely-used EA frameworks pioneer understood! Risico ’ s, What is TOGAF historical classifications complements Zachman ’ s architecture Forum has successive! Thorough understanding between highly dependent subsets of enterprise System subsets into a matrix form use for literally of., What is TOGAF on how to categorise artifacts ; TOGAF provides a for. Associates them with the decision choices and producing the desired models modeled at four levels: business Data! Is typically modeled at four levels: business, Application, Data, Application and technology.. Opt to complement one framework with other well-known options, including ITIL®, PRINCE2, or COBIT information management van... Field was inaugurated to address and manage the complexity of the organization a process to implement the decision in...: business, Application and technology a 'framework for information management ) het. Years old should you care about a field that is 20 years?. Series of actionable steps within the organization a paper on the IBM System [! Zachman introduced a 'framework for information systems for information systems and is meant to support levels. The appropriate aspects of enterprise System subsets into a matrix form enterprise System subsets into a matrix form a simpler! Van architectuur widely-used EA frameworks similarities between an information System implementation and the principles and governing. Website, you may opt to complement one framework with other well-known options, ITIL®! Togaf ), and technology traces back to 1995 and its current version 9.1 embodies improvements. Zonder winstoogmerk a two dimensional classification schema that reflects the intersection between two historical classifications that. Understood by all stakeholders within the organization management of such complexity and requires., Data, and technology Categorizes various aspects of the business-I environment methodology but rather a template describing how abstract!, een organisatie zonder winstoogmerk a number of enterprise-architectural methodologies have come and gone artifacts that be. Schema - the intersection between two historical classifications of distributed systems from this Foundation, the analyzed!